Saturday, June 23, 2007
Male gonads
This was after comment 1 was losttttt In..... SPACEEEEEEEEE
Bollocks!
I'll try to remember what I said, but my original comment was a lyrical triumph of chemical insight, of which this is only a pale grey shadow of ineloquence. I'll try my best though. As I recall, it went a little like this...
OK I'll admit I skirted perilously round the edges of reason in that post, and oversimplified at best. Maybe the point was very much like a point I think you made a while back, viz. that the birds don't care what we think. They'll continue to do what they are doing, even if that is rotting and dissolving to oil, irrespective of our opinions and irrespective of the identity of any video or individual sighting. but fact 1 (maybe FACT 1 - it depends on how hard a day it's been) stands. I will agree that IBWOs were never that easy to see either, but fact (FACT :-)) is that they could be seen, well and repeatedly, with patience, and that there were people who could live and work among them even when their population must have been perilously, perhaps terminally, low. FACT/fact/lie 2 is an oversimplification, but IBWOs could certainly be very conspicuous at times without aspiring to this mythical will-o-the-wisp type level where you can only see them if you're not looking straight at them. I will accept FACT 3 is a little frivolous :-), but will contend that if IBWOs went extinct a few seconds ago, we still wouldn't hear them.
As of OCtober last year I was prepared to believe that although the Arkansas video was a PIWO it miught have inspired some birders to go out and find the real birds in Florida. I absolutely accept the contention that the American birding community gave up on IBWOs too soon. I think it stretches credulity to think that birds, including these hypothesised Florida 9 pairs, could escape the combined digital imagery of all the hair-trigger search teams and goodness knows who else for another search season. Except of course if they aren't there.
Where the heck do those Brits learn English anyway?!
Well I for one learnt it at Swiss finishing school of Upper Class girls. The first sentence of Swiss German they translated into English for me was 'Sir, if you don't stop looking through the window at the girls, we will have to arrest you.'
Thursday, June 21, 2007
Those who live by empiricism will die by empiricism...
Bill came up with sensible comments below in the 'painting the ceiling' post. He ends...
I do wish Cornell would come back up to the plate on this. After all, it's their video, not mine. I've never even claimed to have seen one of these freekin' birds yet I've still been awarded an honorary "crow."
Seems a bit unjust to be given a crow-tag. Maybe someone at Cornell will come up to the plate (is that the same as assuming responsibility for a penalty kick in the shoot-0ut?). But let's face it... it's futile because it is GAME OVER for Ivorybills. Sure it is possible to pick holes in analysis of video artifacts, wingbeats 4-8, deinterlacing, but it does nothing more than delay the obvious which is that Luneau bird was not an Ivorybill. If anyone hangs their hopes for Ivorybills on things that weren't explained in previous papers then those hopes will only last until someone publishes evidence that addresses wingbeat 4-8, deinterlacing and video artifacts. At this point, with the 'double knocks' taking a hammering from gadwalls, the 'kents' being made by anything and not even matching IBWOs very well, all the robobirders picking up extant species of woodpecker, nobody being able to see an IBWO properly, IBWO searchers having to doublethink their way round IBWOs being impossible to see because they are nomadic AND impossible to see because they have very restricted ranges in vast habitat AND have become more difficult to see since they were on the verge of extinction 70 years ago. FACT - IBWOs were never that difficult to see. FACT - their calls were incessant and carried over half a mile. FACT - their calls do NOT carry over 60 years echoing round the woods since the last ones died! No amount of technical rebuttal of any paper will change those things. There is nothing left except a series of sight records that, in isolation, are starting to look like a series of very understandable misidentifications. It was a nice dream while it lasted, but it's time to wake up now. There, I said it. ;-)
Tuesday, June 19, 2007
The creaming of the shrew

And look, I'm not the only one with this perfectly normal fascination...
Sunday, June 17, 2007
I'm meant to be painting the ceiling.
Answer is (are) 'no', and 'I don't know'. But I hope they do. Deal was... my understanding is that the Fitzpatrick et al team were invited to publish a reply alongside my paper at the time of publication, but the ms was not received in time, or at all. BMC Biology Editor has told me that if the rebuttal arrives, I will get chance to reply. So I expect to hear if something is in the pipeline, and I haven't heard anything yet. Of course maybe the rebuttal has arrived and is undergoing peer review before I see it. That is possible. I hope they go for BMC Biol, rather than somewhere easier like the end-of-term report. I've got a few things left behind for replies to replies, and Soggy-bottomed Bill and Dave Martin deserve acknowledgements to their comments, but I have wanted to wait until all the opinions are in.
While we're on the subject... here's another sketch called... YOU CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH WAYS. I thought Ivory-bills were meant to fly with shallow rapid wingbeats, unlike the deep floppy rowing beats of Pileated. Seems to have been a big thing made about that on the recent sightings from Florida and elsewhere, and several people comment on the Luneau bird flapping in an unusual manner for PIWOs. I've argued that all birds, especially big ones, PIWO and IBWO included will bow their wings and flap hard on take off, gaining speed and altitude, and a trip out birding (try it - it's fun!) will confirm that.
SO then you go here (Cornell video analysis site) and click on that video, representing the last clear wingbeat of the Luneau bird. It's meant to be showing the white on the back. I'm not sure what to make of the white. If you believe (as you have to if you want the Luneau bird to be an IBWO) that white bleeds when you want it to but doesn't bleed when you don't, then it's conceivable that this represents the dorsal stripes of an IBWO. Equally (as proposed by Sibley and colleagues) it could be white from the head, or light reflecting off a black back, or some other weird artifact. But ignore the white for a second. What the video has done by putting that last wingbeat on a loop has shown how the bird flies as it is relaxing into level flight. And looky here, it's flying like a PIWO?? Deep and floppy, and wings extended. So either IBWOs can fly like PIWOs, or that isn't an IBWO?? Comments please.
Before Bill starts... :-) I'm not yet committing on whether its me that wants it both ways, or the True Believers.
All this, and birding too
However, Sunday morning, today, after a good sleep, 50 kg of Fathers' Day chockies and a delivery of high quality Colombian cocaine (lying about the cocaine, in case you were wondering), I was reborn... the pep is back and I went out at 9 am... to see not much, but this time it didn't matter.
Must be hard work being a Common Blackbird - one with an crippled foot was hopping along the track by the burn, still seeing off a rival male in spite of his injury. A Blackcap was singing from the bushes exactly where that Garden Warbler was a couple of weeks ago. They have very simialr habitat preferences and compete for territories, in a mutually exclusive manner. I know it must be true cos I made it up myself/read it in a book. Decide for yourself which of those options is likely to be true. Tbh, not sure that even I know any more.
Offshore, from 10-11 am (when the sun got in my eyes, I spied3 Red-throated Divers going north, and 1 south. You can't beat summer divers. I guess by now these are non-breeders, for whatever reason? 4 Manx Shearwaters north. 2 Arctic Skuas (Parasitic Jaegers) north, 4 Sandwich Terns south. Also a bit of a passage of Common Scoters (IOC: Black Scoters, now there's a mad mad mad decision) with 96 north. Occurred to me that one day I'll spot a Surfie from here, given that I see 1000s Common Scoters over the course of the year. It'll be a McEwans Export day when that happens.
In the gardens at the corner of Newton Road, there was a fresh hybrid Carrion x Hooded Crow high in the pines. And hungry. It actually looked very hoodie... smooth grey bits, not speckled or very dark like most of the hybrids round here.
I didn't get a photo of it... but I did get this snail. Phonecam again.
Scooped!
But to my dismay, I find that Tom has beaten me to it. Reasonably funny too, but not as good as mine, except I can't do mine now cos it will look like I copied. I was in a better position to dish the dirt too. I'm going to claim this title for my new series
'The Secret Diary of Bernard Tucker (deceased)'
before that Manc gets it.
I agree with Tom... there is SO MUCH information available for free on the internet (that's this, in case you didn't know) that it becomes increasingly difficult to justify printing a magazine. BUT most months, I find that pretty much everything I see in the other British magazines was pretty much available in some form online, whereas British Birds publishes things you can't get anywhere else.
Ad-break over.
Lest we forget
Go here for the full horror.
Very old, but surprisingly near the top when you google me. I think it gets a lot of hits from people looking for penguin prostitutes.
Birdchick is amusing
This is VERY educational
IBWOs not particularly wary. Rarely possible to stay onto them for more than an hour at a time!
A Little Cracker
... not much about cage and aviary birds. There's rather a lot about wild birds - these folks are genuine bird enthusiasts. So there's news about birds' intelligence, Song Sparrows suppressing sickness during breeding, declinign wild birds and conservation, Black-billed Magpies and their undeserved bad reputation, White-breasted Dippers, and a page about bill morphology and adaptations. Three cheers.
Bird joke of the week... a boy took his parrot to the vet because it was unwell. The vet said: "Yes, I can see the problem. It has a millet spray up one nostril, a carrot stick under its wing and sunflower seeds all over its head. It's obviously not eating properly."
For sale:
Not much of interest to us. Except...
Long-tailed Rosefinch, cock, £70
(I wonder how much the rest of it costs? - boom BOOM!)
I might have said this before, but I think L-t rosefinch is a potential vagrant. breeds in the Western Pal, follows an E-W migration - bound to overshoot into Western Europe some spring.
Also, for reasons I can't begin to imagine, they have given enormous prominence to this photograph of a gorgeous young Humboldt Penguin. A phone number too, if you want to get more information.
Thursday, June 14, 2007
Monday, June 11, 2007
Another dull morning, with a surprisingly chilly NW breeze, and a Roe Deer feeding in the 'Reed Bunting' bushes at the top of the track. I've never known a year as good as this for jamming into Roe Deers. In fact I guess there's 4-5 of them around (2 m and 3 f), and they're all pretty much used to me. This one was unconcerned by me standing 10 m away. If I'd broken into my Ian Paisley impression or blasted out a rousing chorus of 'Jerusalem' it might have objected, but I didn't so it didn't.
Pishing produced no Reed Buntings out of those bushes, but did bring up a pair of Song Thrushes carrying food. Another new successful breeding was at the Mill Garden where I saw a Pied Wagtail carrying food, and then a fluffy juv Pied Wag with a pathetically small tail. I raised* a juvvy Pied Wag once. It came out of a nest in the vents of the Medical Research Council building in Edinburgh. We called it 'Chisick', cos that's all it ever said. Infested with mites that crawled out all over my hands.
*I say raised... I mean killed. It didn't live.
A pair of Black-billed Magpies were systematically working the hawthorn bushes along the track, looking for nests and nestlings, I'll wager.
2 broods of Mallards on the burn down by the beach - 5 v small (1/8) duckings and 1 bigger (2/8) effort.
Half an hour looking offshore... smells like summer, but the sea was dead quiet... 52 Northern Gannets north, and 22 south, 3 Manx Shearwaters north (1 south) 1 Red-throated Diver north, and 1 Arctic Tern. Also another display (see below) by 3-4 Bottle-nosed Dolphins, including what I think was a mum + calf (big one swimming in synchrony and v close to a little one). An Atlantic Grey Seal off the rocks too.
The allotments were even more boring, but there was a Sand Martin/Bank Swallow (some sort of wanderer/mibrant) over the fallow field south of there. Also 2 Northern Lapwings still nesting, annoyed at local dogs and quite rightly.
Remains of dead vole (sp.) looking surprised. Mostly surprised that I had managed to set the phone to video.Friday 8th June
The pair of Reed Buntings still present in the bushes by the burn at the top of the track, and a Roe Deer in the bushes at the railway bridge. 22 Common Eiders in the bay, a juvenile Common Starling feeding among the seaweed on the beach (they learn fast) and wtf - a fresh juvenile Common Stonechat in the vegetation up the cliff sides - where the hell did THAT come from?
Offshore, 06:30 - 07:00 (exactly - I used the atomic clock), there was 1 Great Skua going north, and a gorgeous adult Arctic Skua (Parasitic Jaeger) giving its full and undivided attention to a feeding flock of Black-legged Kittiwakes. 13 Common Scoters went north, 3 Red-throated Divers, 5 Manx Shearwaters, 4 Common Swifts (eh?) and 17 Northern Gannets. Better than that, a pod of Bottle-nosed Dolphins including one breaching, going almost entirely out of the water several times, turning in mid-air and slamming back into the water on its back. I guess it could have been removing a particularly troublesome parasite, but I prefer to assume it was having fun.
Thursday, June 07, 2007
Wednesday 6th June
Otherwise it was all very dull EXCEPT 30 min looking offshore when there was quite a bit about, i.e. 4 Manx Shearwaters, an Arctic Skua (Parasitic Jaeger) harassing the Black-legged Kittiwakes, 46 Northern Gannets north , 6 Arctic Terns north , 1 Sandwich Tern, 10 Red-throated Divers north (where the hell did they come from? been none around for a couple of weeks), 3 Common Scoters north (with a flock of Puffins!), and a Bottle-nosed Dolphin out feeding.
As Jesus said to the Pharisees, there's just no pleasing some people :-)
btw, re earlier postings, I'm also forced to state that 'by the same taken I think it's unlikely that our paper girl's bike is made from baby deers.'
Monday, June 04, 2007
Unqualified praise...
I like it when people praise my work, and I am too naive to spot sarcasm. FMFMF must have been too impressed by my kents to check the scales of the WTD bleat and FL 'kents' because they are the same length. Thinner is just the parameters of the sonagram contrast and brightness, prob nothing to do with the calls. Different shape I will buy. But then again... here is a sonagram of some real kent calls from the archival audio here. Thanks to Syrinx
Don't get me started, but I'm really not sure that these are a better match for the FL kents than the deer. The shapes are better, but the frequencies are wrong and the calls of the real IBWOs are too short. I'm happy to accept that the WTD bleat is not the same as the FL kent, if by the same token we accept it is unlikely that the FL kents are the same as the IBWO kents.While I'm here... I said don't get me started, but now I've started... look at the now-infamous wingbeats at 1.6-2.6 seconds. There is NO WAY that bird is tanking away from the microphone like the Luneau video bird. Think of the ground it would be covering - the flaps would fade away to nothing, but instead what there is here is 9 flaps of relatively equal amplitude, that stop suddenly. I think it's very likely that this bird was just fluttering its wings, or at the most going between 2 branches in a tree. Not comparable to Pileateds or IBWOs in level flight Apples and oranges :-O
Btw, if I remember my 20 year-ago lecture notes properly, as birds get bigger, mass increases as a function of length to the power three, whereas wing area only increases as a function of length to the power two, so bigger birds, all things being equal, tend to have more mass to be carried per unit wing area than smaller birds. To compound that, my understanding is that most of the lift provided by a wing is a function of the length of the front edge. That's why bigger birds eg IBWOs have proportionately longer wings, narrower to reduce drag, than smaller birds e.g. PIWOs. They gain lift at the expense of the manouevrability afforded by broader shorter wings
A big bird like IBWO has a mechanic problem about how to maintain lift cf a smaller bird like PIWO. According to Gill's textbook, 'Ornithology', what I was reading the other day, in general birds increase lift by increasing flight speed - not by flapping faster. There are exceptions when there are other constraints on the wings (e.g. Auks) but in level flight energy considerations mean that in general big birds will in fact flap more slowly. The bones and tendons for the wings act as a pendulum which resonates to minimise energy use during flight. Long wings are longer pendulums with an inherently slower natural frequency. So intuitively I would expect an IBWO certainly to fly faster than a PIWO, but I can't think why it would flap faster. Indeed this would go against the trend for other N american woodpeckers, for which (as I remember - correct me if wrong) the Tobalske work showed that in level flight the flap rates slow down with increasing size.
Other things... if the 2006/7 Florida search really has failed (6th June update) , I think that reduces the chances of Ivory-bills being alive to about 0.1%. if I'm generous, which I am.I was reading Hill's 'Ivorybill Hunters' and enjoying it very much, from a birding perspective - can't fault the effort. Can't help but like the folks involved either. Future ornithology archaeologists will sift through the bones of that book and try to reconstruct how expectation alone could bring a bird back from the dead.
Double knocks could be Gadwalls smacking into each other in flight, apparently. Now that would be funny to see.
Other things that would be funny to see - I did see them, but you didn't so I will describe. On the way back from Peterborough on Saturday night, two blokes got onthe train at Dundee and one of them was so drunk he hadn't noticed his pants were on fire! He'd been smoking on the platform, in contravention of Scottish law, I might add, and stuck the butt in his back pocket, and walked down the carriage with smoke coming out of his arse. Excuse me mate, you're on fire! And he was sober enough to come up with a funny gag - 'I'm just wearing my smoking jacket!' Then his pal, we shall call him bloke 2, lay down across the seats with his big fat hairy stomach poking above the level of the table for all to see. I was ending myself and texting Diane to tell her what was going on. Just as it couldn't get any worse, bloke 2 farted! At Arbroath they both dashed out, relit that cigarette, took one puff and got back on the train. Only in Scotland. Mind Bloke 1 was Irish. Not sure what to make of that.
Sunday, June 03, 2007
I can see Hayley now Lorraine has gone
I've been busy, and am a bit behind on the ol' blogoid. So here's the low-lights of the past week or so.
Sunday 27th May
Shite. A fresh cold NW wind. A pair of Sedge Warblers with nest material in the dead Willow, being bugged persistently by a female House Sparrow for no obvious reason, unless she can't be bothered collecting her own nest stuff. Family parties of Starlings all over the shop, filling the air with their annoying scratchy vocalisations.
The Garden Warbler sang briefly from the bushes down the track.
I startled and then grilled a juvenile Rock Pipit freshly out along the clifftops. Distinctive appearance- heavily streaked below, no supercilium, white eye ring, tail short, constantly bobbed.
Offshore very boring but a few Northern Gannets and Sandwich Terns.
Wednesday 30th May.
Wet wet wet! I feel it in my fingers, I feel it in my boots. My DMs have developed a massive slit along the side. Not ideal for puddles. Seeing very little apart from the stuff I really can't miss. A female Mallard with 1 1/8 duckling were trying to shelter from the rain under the sleeper-bridge. But I flushed them and made them go out in it. Hell, if I'm miserable, so should they be.
A few Common Scoters going south today (22 in 20 min offshore); 1 Manx Shearwater north, and 50 Atlantic Puffins moving past north - constant trickle.
Friday 1st June
Bit of an SE breeze and some fog - this is more like it! Except it isn't. A Willow Warbler carrying food in the Mill Garden has got a move on. I pished up a Roe Deer from the bushes down the track to the beach! On the beach, a juvenile Grey Wagtail being fed by the male. Two Peregrine Falcons flew by in formation. A tasty-looking dead juv Starling at the allotments, where a Dunnock was hauling a fecal sac round for fun. Everything soggy.
Saturday 2nd June.
This is more like it! Down at Steve Dudley's house, Farcet Fen, near Peterborough. Top Secret BOURC meeting at an undisclosed location (observer's name withheld) nearby. Hauled myself out of bed and wandered off down the road pre-brekkie. Almost immediately a Eurasian Hobby flew over, carrying something that looked like a Barn Swallow, and probably was. About 5 minutes later, a Barn Owl floating over the road, also carrying prey. Also delighted to hear some Corn Buntings singing (and got a recording and sonagram) and even better (with apologies to southern softies who don't understand this) recordings of calls of a pair of Yellow Wagtails (still not on my Scottish List). (Although, tbh I don't have a Scottish List). (But if I did, Yellow Wag ain't on it).
Other things I wouldn't normally get in sunny Newtonhill included Reed Warbler and Red-legged Partridge (walking along the road - not so strange, that's what I was doing too).
Was disappointed not to get Turtle Dove (had to make do with Tree Sparrow) but at least heard one at Egleton later.
International criminal known only as 'El Toadsnatcher' is wanted for the cruel murder of this Winter Wren. If you have information about this crime, please write in. Or if you can guess the weight of the Wren, it's quite possible you will win it.

Note that the bird is much less barred along the back than our northern Scotland jobbies. Maybe Phillip Clancey was right about T. t. indigenus.
Sunday 3rd June
Back to normal. Arrived back late last night. A Red-backed Shrike at Girdleness. Couldn't be bothered going 5 miles out of my way, so resolved to find my own. Bad move. I was left looking at a couple of Willow Warblers in the Mill Garden. Y'know, WWs do bob their tails like Common Chiffchaffs. Often accompanied as part of a wing-flick action, but not always.
A nice yellow-billed Common Eider on the beach, paired with a female (the best way to achieve successful fertilisation).

Offshore - in about 30 min were 5 Manx Shearwaters heading north, 100 + Northern Gannets, 3 Sandwich Terns and a Common Tern. Plenty Puffins, + the other 2 auks, Kittiwakes and Fulmars. See although I complain about my patch that I don't get Corn Buntings, Yellow Wagtails etc, I bet Steve struggles for Puffins and Gannets on the Fen. The ideal combined patch would be a piece of continental-climate lowland farmland, sticking out into the North Sea. I think they call it N0rfolk.Friday, May 25, 2007
It's a fair cop
Thursday, May 24, 2007
The Ivory-billed Woodpecker persists in North-east Scotland
Wednesday 23rd May
Pre-work birding, mostly boring. The Sedge Warbler wasn't there at the top of St Ann's track, hope it's OK. Compensated by a Garden Warbler singing from the trees down to the beach - a patch year tick (get 1-2 birds a year).
Offshore, an eclectic 'feeding flock' of 1 Grey Seal (with a fish) 1 adult Northern Gannet, 1 Black-legged Kittiwake and 1 Northern Fulmar.
Thursday 24th May
Still no Sedge Warbler singing at St Ann's... oohhhhh.. but then again most of the others are pretty silent too this morning. I couldn't stop bumping into Roe Deer today - male and female charged past me top speed, then I startled another female as she wandered onto the Beach track in front of me, then I stalked another male for 400 m down the same track. The Garden Warbler was still singing, as from yesterday. Juvenile White-throated Dipper spotted again on the burn.
Offshore, Atlantic Puffins, Common Guillemots and Razorbills all bathing enthusiastically - you'd think spending your winter out at sea would put you off splashing about for fun, but apparently not.
Recycling day again in Newtonhill, and once again the folk at no. 63 have spent a fortnight tanking nothing but McEwan's Export. At 57, in contrast, they have subsisted on red wine and Diet Coke. Not together, I hope.
On my way back to the house I had a compelling audio contact with Ivory-billed Woodpecker. Obviously this isn't proof, but I am presenting the evidence as I got it so you can assess it for yourself. The sound file of 2 'kent' calls is presented here.
I made a sonagram (some people say I have too much time on my hands, but they're just annoyed cos I've been stalking them the past 6 months). Here it is, on the right, in comparison with the published Florida 'kent' and a bleat of a White-tailed Deer.
The habitat was not typical for Ivory-billed Woodpecker - being a steep-sided valley with only bracken and wild roses for cover, within 10 m of permanent human habitation.I'll tell you what was making that noise tomorrow. Clue, it wasn't a Pileated Woodpecker, it has wayyy too much white and lacked the rounded wings and deep lazy flight of that species.
Sunday, May 20, 2007
A Small Victory

Juvvy European Robin (alive this time - yesterday's bird must have got better), juvvy European Goldfinches in Mill Garden. Also a very grey acredula type Willow Warbler feeding in the sycamores here.Mystery photograph (no peeping below)
Yes, I found a juvvy Song Thrush. It appeared to have twatted itself against the wall and hurt its wing. I was picking it up to bump it off for my lunch (joke - but I was going to see if it had broken anything. Don't have much truck with wildlife rehabilitation), but it fluttered off into the Mill Garden, so it wasn't completely crippled, maybe just stunned. So I left it to a prolonged death.Female Mallard with 2 small ducklings on the burn, with 2 Common Swifts over the village. There's been an enormous hatch of those annoying nasty black flies with the dangly legs (St Mark's Flies?), and the Swifts, Barn Swallows, House Martins and even Vulgar Starlings were making merry among them.
A feeding flock of 200 Black-legged Kittiwakes offshore had several 1st summer birds, checking out the territory (it's wet).
I took an alternative route down to Muchalls, over a few walls and along the coastal fields. Some good setaside (or maybe just useless) fields, awash with weeds and occasionally purple with pansies, which are also weeds(!). Also a Northern Wheatear, looking very like a leucorhoa, was a patch year tick - embarrassing, but I've found Northern Wheatears to be surprisingly scarce along this bit of coast, and am more likely to pick up these Greenland or Iceland birds later in the spring than I am to get an early spring local breeder. I made a rat's arse of trying to photograph it. See orange and grey blur behind nicely in focus flowers.

This is what this field looks like. Spectaclier. In here was a pair or Northern Lapwings, and I found a Skylark nest, which was a pretty good effort.
This way took me to the back of Water Valley, and I had an unpleasant time trying to hack my way through the undergrowth on the north side of that burn. Saw Chaffinches, Yellowhammers, Great Tits, jaggy gorse. A rare photograph of me in the field. One at a time please, ladies. :-O
It's a bit lame, but I'm frequently asked if I have a photo (at least I was while IBWOs were still a live issue), and in all my photos of me I'm desk-bound or pissed*. Sometimes both. This one is neither.*Or naked in a bath of rose petals. That's a speciality market. Not very popular, tbh.
Thursday 17th and Saturday 20th May
Thursday:
Beautiful Sedge Warbler displays Thursday morning, and two Willow Warblers checking out nest sites in the gorse next to the Elsick Burn. I'm seeing Roe Deer more or less daily just now, and today was no different with one a point blank range in the bushes by the track. Caught a Song Thrush carrying food to a nest near the white houses by the beach.
A single Great Skua went north in 20 min looking, and 7 Manx Shearwaters, flying close to shore so nearly slipped under the radar. 45 Northern Gannets north, and a single Arctic Tern fishing among a feeding flock of Black-legged Kittiwakes about 500 m off the cliffs. Also 3 spp auks and several Northen Fulmars.
Saturday:
Found this on the track - a dead European Robin, juvvy. I love the way things work in the Real World - no apologies, no excuses, no explanations, no second chances. I couldn't have designed it better myself. Sorry baby Robin, you were just too shit for this life.
Had a leisurely attempt at photographing a Roe Deer on the other side of the burn. Disappointed to ifnd out after I had the phone cam set on lo-res, so have suffered a bit. These are the best...

...unfortunately. Not last one - I call it 'Deer's arse with ?Sedge Warbler blur'.Offshore... this was funny. I saw 35 Northern Gannets heading south, but the way the light was this morning shining through their wings, they looked weird. Then another flock of 10 came through, and I was thinking that this time it was making them look like shelducks or something then I realised that this was a flock of 10 Common Shelducks. A scarce migrant here. Wake up Martin. 1 Arctic Skua went north, at some lick.
Wednesday, May 16, 2007
It's always funny until someone gets hurt...
Birding this morning again. Fantastic dawn chorus, if you count Sedge Warblers, in a fresh south-easterly breeze. Infact, we've gained some more - 7 Sedgies singing along the burn this morning. I bet if I pick up another couple the other way tomorrow, I'll have a patch record. I'm glad my life isn't sad.
Also a Common Swift over the village was a patch year tick - noticably late. I only saw my first swifts of the year at all yesterday - 50 over the Bridge of Dee.
A Peregrine was over the cliffs. 3 Red-throated Divers going north offshore, and 1 male Common Scoter. 4 Sandwich Terns feeding with a flock of 100 Black-legged Kittiwakes just off the surf.
Messed around getting come more recordings of common birds singing. All this keeps me amused but still not exactly setting the heather alight.
it would be funny if it wasn't true... this appeared on ebn today, posted by a Dutch birder.
Claim of Slender-billed Curlew
When I was in Divjaka, Albania on May 6th I went to the lagoon early
in the morning, intended to see the Dalmatian Pelican. I saw some of
them the afternoon before, but wanted to have a closer view and if
possible picture them. I walked at the edge of a pinewood, bordering
the fields. When I did so, I reached a canal, at this point I turned
to the left, and tried to walk to the beach. After passing the last
pines, a flat and wet area stretched out, bordered by a lake.
Heathenlike plants grew on it, tough and usual only up to 30
centimetres high. Under those plants the soil was so wet, that at most
places you could hardly walk without getting wet feet. Also there were
many small puddles. At the border, alongside the canal, a path led in
the right direction, I meant (but after a walk of 15-30 minutes it was
cut of by another canal, so I had to turn round and didn't reach the
main area, nor the beach).
I took the path from the pines alongside the wet area of heathenlike
plants, and suddenly two frightened birds flew away, obviously being
curlews, with the sound of a disturbed Curlew, but not as massive as
this bird calls. This sound was lighter, more joyfull. Also the birds
were somewhat smaller and paler, brighter then the Curlew I know well
from The Netherlands. I couldn't see much of the details, I needed a
few seconds to realise what I was looking at: two Slender-billed
Curlews!! I knew I had a very good observation, but didn't know some
birders thought the bird was already extinct.
The Slender-billed Curlews flew some hundreds of metres away and
disappeared on the edge of the wetland and the lake. I didn't see them
again, although I followed the path in their direction. At some point
the sight was hasseled by bushes, high enough to give the birds the
opportunity to fly away unseen. Other curlews flew up from the
wetland, being almost always undoubtedly Curlews, which were in groups
of up to eight individuals together. I heard the sound of a Whimbrel
amongst them one time, but couldn't find this bird.
The next day I departed, not knowing the species is at the edge of
extinction. In my opinion it was surely a very rare and sought after
bird, but due to it's far-off life in countries almost without
birders, I thought there should be some 400 (or so) individuals left.
As I liked to go to Lake Ohrid and Lake Prespa on my trip through
Albania, I didn't break my travels down to spend more time on the
Slender-billed Curlews.
When I went to the Karavasta Lagoon, I didn't realise this could be an
area where a Slender-billed Curlew was possible. So I was not focussed
on getting this bird, never thought I should see it. But when I saw
those small and pale curlews, I was convinced determination was right.
And I am convinced yet, after a few discussions on Dutch online
birdingsites. I can agree with the people who show a lot of criticism
about those birds, and so I realise this description will not be
enough to get the birds accepted. But may be it throws more attention
on the area. The birds are seen in a wetland which isn't protected at
all: hunting, fishing, pollution with rubbish, dogs walking free over
the area and recreation disturbes the birds, wildlife and flora
oncontrolled. The Albanian gouvernment is not able to stop this.
Although the real park is situated at the other side of the canal I
mentioned, I don't think this area will be better protected. At the
other side I even saw more fishermen and I from time to time I heard
the sound of rifles.
Divjaka is situated south of Durrës, I guess some 40 kilometres.
Google Earth provides me with the coördinates of the site of this
record: 41°0'43.40"N, 19°28'52.68"E (but I don't know how precise
Google Earth is).
I know many questions on which I can't give any answer will remain,
but I had no time enough to make photo's of the birds and I am not
able to make a better description - I just told you what I saw,
without making the story better then it is. Nontheless I hope this
will bring people to the coastal lagoons of Albania for further
research. I don't have any other interest in it, then the protection
of nature in common, and especially of saving the Slender-billed Curlew.
I guess it might be possible to create a scenario that's more like the IBWO fiasco, but I'm not sure how. In fact I think there's more similarity between Slender-billed Curlews and Ivorybills than we care to admit. Both are very probably extinct. Slender-billed Curlew isn't as bad because there were undisputed and very well documented sightings until the early 1990s. The there is the Druridge Bay 1997 bird which was videoed and published, and shows diagnostic features of Slender-billed Curlew, but is still not universally accepted (especially by those who dipped!). And then, with the bird having been 'rediscovered', there are a number of sightings, some by very reputable ornithologists across Europe, but which like this one can never be quite fully proven... but are used as a reason for conserving the habitat. Nothing wrong with that of course, but when a potential Slender-bill hangs around for long enough to be properly grilled (Minsmere), it turns out to be a Eurasian Curlew. All the 'Slenderbills' get away. Sorry mate, they got away a while back. As they say, it's funny until someone gets hurt.
Monday, May 14, 2007
Move into '92, still in a room without a view
Got to Blackdog, parked carefully so as to annoy any large items of farm machinery, and scanned to sea - big scoter flock to the south, so set off at healthy stomp pace. Set up on the sand dunes about 1 km to the south and pretty much the first bird I saw (well maybe the tenth) was Coco the Clown, drake Surf Scoter. I made the mistake of trying a phone-scope photo, leading to this disaster. I'm not even sure it's visible.

Worse, as I was trying to get some other shots, it was flushed by a helicopter and flew off with 20 others down south towards Bridge of Don. Nice while it lasted. There were about 500 Common Scoters on the water, a single Long-tailed Duck for good measure, and maybe 500+ Common Eiders. Who's counting? And 20 Red-throated Divers - looks like I'm counting.
Very disappointed because Blackdog is usually a shoe-in for a disgusting corpse of something on the tideline, but I was out of luck today. The children will go hungry tonight.
Sunday 13th May
Offshore was boring too - 30 minutes produced 3 Common Scoters north, a Red-throated Diver in flight being slipstreamed by 2 Razorbills, and a Whimbrel. Must be a good year for Whimbrel - they're all over the shop.
Muchalls was alive with common birds, and I saw Peregrine, Common Buzzard, Common Kestrel and some Yellowhammers on the way down, but... boring. And still cold!
Friday, May 11, 2007
I did what I thought was right. yeh.
In 20 min offshore, 6 Manx Shearwaters north, 3 Red-throated Divers, 57 Northern Gannets, and 2 Sandwich Terns.
Sedge Warbler singing here. Note impressions of Willow Warbler + Oystercatcher, in particular
and the same bird a minute or so later here - note impressions of Grey Wagtail, Barn Swallow, Great Tit, Chaffinch and others.
See those Willow Warbler-type 'hooeets' it does - I put them next to my 'real' WW hooeet on this sonagram so you can see how similar they are. They're the asymmetric 'U's on the image below. Credits to Remembird and Syrinx
Thursday, May 10, 2007
Ythan Estuary

And a not inconsiderable number of Common Eiders (more than would be typical in Newtonhill, for example)

I skived out of work early as there was a birders' social evening in Newburgh and I spied the opportunity to do a bit of birding on the Ythan beforehand. It was well worth it too. Started by the golf club looking over the river to Sands of Forvie, and the place was crawling with birds. About 800 Common Eiders (some of them in that flock above). They were making a bit of noise, but nothing compared to the 100+ Black-headed Gulls flocking about, who were in turn bugging about 100 Sandwich Terns and 40 Arctic Terns on the opposite shore. Quite a few Common Terns around too, and after a few minutes there were 6-10 Little Terns flickering about. Scanned through the terns on the deck, and picked up 2 1st summer Little Gulls. When a helicopter went over, the whole lot flushed, and the Little Gulls flew round and round, attempting to land in the gull/tern colony but were industriously chased off by an aggressive trio of Black-headed Gulls.
Scanning round the river... 7 Red-breasted Mergansers, and a single female Long-tailed Duck, with some Northern Gannets and a couple of Red-throated Divers going north offshore.
In the mud, a few Common Shelducks, 11 Ruddy Turnstones, 8 Ringed Plovers, 18 Dunlin, and an absolutely stunning Whimbrel, really strong head pattern. Only about 50 Herring Gulls around, with one or 2 Great Black-backed Gulls, and 1 Lesser Black-back.
Round to the north side of the river (Yellowhammers, Common Stonechats and Willow Warblers in the gorse at the golf club) I walked up the path along the shore, passing hundreds of ridiculously tame eiders. There were several Northern Lapwings on the rough ground to the north, and a Common Buzzard bugging them as it looked for chicks etc. 4 Bar-tailed Godwits on the mud along here, with 1 Eurasian Curlew and then another 5 Whimbrels... see photo :-$
I was trying to take a photo of that blurry Whimbrel in the foreground, all phone-cams. Note bill colours of the Eiders, btw. The majority of the eiders here had 'typical' green-grey bills, maybe up to 5% with predominantly yellow bills.

Seven more spanking Ruddy Turnstones, sniffing each others' bums, and a couple of Eurasian Wigeon.
that's an eider in the photo, btw, not a wigeon, but you would have spotted that for yourself.I walked all the way along to the tern colony fenced-off bit, and looking out over the river from this new angle... more eiders and rb mergansers, and a pair of Greater Scaup! Outrageous. Cooking on gas, but still freezing. I walked back - only new birds a pair of Grey Partridge on the rough ground. In 2 1/2 hours I'd seen loads of birds that are hen's teeth back on the patch.
The Ythan - a celebration of DEATH

Poking through the recycling
Onshore passerines were dull again, though we've picked up a couple more singing Sedge Warblers and Common Whitethroats down the burn.
It's recycling day at Newtonhill, so I got a good look into people's lifestyles as I was walking back home before anyone else got up. From the people who try to recycle cigarette packets (it makes smoking socially responsible), to the people at no. 63 who have subsisted this past week solely on cans of McEwans Export, it would appear, and the clean-living folk at no. 59 who drink naught but the finest bottled water. Mmmm... I hate myself for this, but I love McEwans export. Haven't had it for years, but I will this weekend.
Tuesday, May 08, 2007
Happy Birthday
This morning, north side of the Elsick Burn, a Willow Warbler singing, answered by a Common WhitethroatClick here to listen to 'Common-Whitethroat-and-Willow-Warbler-NE-Scotland-May-07'
Monday, May 07, 2007
Sunday morning
tbh there's not a lot to say. Rain overnight spectacularly failed to bring any more migrants down. There was a White-throated Dipper carrying food under the railway bridge, but I still haven't found the nest this year. A male Chaffinch was flying around the Mill Garden trying to force down and mount a female. Common Whitethroats, Willow Warblers and 3 Sedge Warblers singing down the track to the beach. 1 Ruddy Turnstone with 24 Common Eiders on the rocks. Offshore was very boring, with only a few Northern Gannets back and forth. I went round Cran Hill and met this monstrousity...
That's not just a pile of manure... it looked like the entire winter's detritus scraped up from the bottom of the cowshed and placed menacingly over the field facing Newtonhill. When that's spread it spells our doom. I mean, working in a University (I'm the Head of the Department of Cryptozoology remember? If a joke's funny the first time it's funny every time I say) I'm no stranger to the spell of bullshit, but jeeezz this was rank. I was retching as this photo was taking. They should figure out a way of doing Blogger3 with live retchavision. I'm getting the dry boke just thinking about it, 2 days later. There was a hybrid Hooded x Carrion Crow kept sitting on it, the malodorous fool, but thwarting my attempts at a photo by flying off every time I aimed the camera.










Quite a comparison there between the IBWO and the WTD, apart from the WTD squiggles being shorter, and thinner, and differently shaped. Damned conclusive, I'd say! Good work!